aditya's blog

Writings on Opensource, WordPress, Technology, Books, Movies and more.

/

Thoughts on the light that could be WordCamp India!


Traditional brass lamp using melted butter as fuel.
Traditional brass lamp using melted butter as fuel. by Bigul Malayi is licensed under CC-CC0 1.0

The rarefied micro-community of WordPress users who travel to WordCamps and run small to large WordPress projects around India, have been talking about an interesting project: WordCamp India!

A large multi-day WordCamp of thousands of people coming and doing cool WordPress things with maybe a couple of hundred folks from around the world, with large enterprise agencies, product companies and more.

A large event like this is probably the only chance for a lot of people in India to attend a WordPress conference of that size and stature because of finances involving a foreign trip and of course visa regimes.

It is hard to argue against the value that an event like this would unlock.

But there are also fears of consolidation of sponsor support and organiser time.Some of these things I want to write are really from my perspective. I am not suggesting this is some researched article. But I have been around the WordPress community team long enough (almost a decade now) and have seen these things happen over the years.

Costs of Consolidation

Sponsors: Sponsors would rather spend time and money on one large event once a year rather than several smaller ones. This makes a lot of operational sense to sponsors. This introduces a higher load on event organisers from smaller events to find new sponsors.

Event Organisers: Event organisers from smaller communities also end up getting involved in the large event, and if they are not sponsored (paid to work in open source) they will prioritise the larger events. In reality, even paid contributors do this, so I expect this is even harder for unpaid volunteer contributors. As a result, we will possibly see the unintended consequence of weakening local communities.

Possible Side Effects

  1. Stagnating Community: As the local communities struggle with events newer people might not find it as enjoyable or fun to get involved. This will lead to stagnation
  2. Local events fade out: While big fancy events in resorts might thrive, no one will be around to get into the weeds and help local events grow. Local communities will eventually fade out.
  3. The Big Event will eventually decline: Well if all the local communities feel the pressure, and a system that only takes from the smaller communities (both sponsor money, organiser and speaker talent), new things will not happen, we will have the big event finally becoming jaded and possibly also decline over time.

Okay, Are you against WordCamp India?

No, I am not.

I want WordCamp India to happen and fuel WordPress growth in India. But before we put out an order this fuel we need the engines in place and that we do not have as yet. 

I would not want us to soak everything in fuel as a small misstep there on will set fire to everything.

If we are to organise WordCamp India – we should try to pick up this gauntlet that we could set out as a challenge for ourselves.

The Pre- WCIndia Challenge

  1. Get 50 local meetup groups active that meet in person atleast once a month.
  2. Have 20 active year WordCamps in Indian cities.

In reality, currently India had 5 WordCamps in 2023. We are probably going to have 7 (Pune, Bengaluru, Delhi, Kerala, Ahmedabad, Mumbai, Kolkata) and a possibly a small experimental one in Kolhapur and another one in a Tier 3 city.🤞

In meetups, we have about 22 active meetups in India and 21 inactive. So that number of 50 is not as far fetched. I do think we can add a lot more value with cross community online events but more on that in a another post.

Twenty cities big & small hosting day long conferences, and fifty hosting regular meetups groups would be powerful engines of the WordPress community which can justify and use this fuel, that an event like WordCamp India would unleash.

A Post- WCIndia Thought experiment*

*subject to community risks

Okay, lets do a post WordCamp India thought experiment. What would the world be like after we achieve those goals and organise a very large event like WordCamp India?

Fifty active meetups and Twenty active WordCamps would mean hundreds if not thousands of individuals who would be exposed to the WordPress project as possible contributors. Also that’s just a start, there is no need to stop at 50|20. 🙃

New people, younger people in the community from several different parts of the country with thriving local communities would mean several more ecosystems around translations, publishing, training and skill development.

So hopefully, WordCamp India – if and when it happens, would not be “just another big WordCamp event”.

Credits
Many thanks to Pooja Derashri, Naoko Takano, Julia Golomb and Ratnesh Sonar for giving me some valuable feedback and adding more perspectives.


7 responses to “Thoughts on the light that could be WordCamp India!”

  1. subrataatemfluence Avatar
    subrataatemfluence

    Hi Aditya, WordCamp India is always on the card! It should happen sooner or later. And yes, there will be some definite pre and post effects some of those you have already mentioned here. On this light, I can think of zonal WordCamps too. Like East, West, North and South India WordCamps. In many Indian cities, we hardly find an active community even they have the potential. These zonal WCs might wake them up! However, there will still be city based events, may be mostly the next gen ones like Kolkata had hosted the first Career Camp in 2024!

    1. Aditya Avatar

      I like the idea of several cities having their own micro-communities and then WCIndia be the travelling circus that comes to town every once in few years 😀

  2. Patricia BT Avatar

    Hello Aditya

    It’s very nice to see that you are thinking about it! I would love to come back to India and what’s best than a WordCamp for that

    About your list of possible side-effects (Stagnating Community, Local events fade out, The Big Event will eventually decline), I know we cannot compare, but about WordCamp Europe, when the first one was organised in 2013, it sparked enthusiasm and generated a lot of local activity everywhere.

    I recently talked with Remkus de Vries (co-org of the first WCEU) and here is what he says (from the video transcript):
    (you can see from minute 8:00 in this video)

    we didn’t necessarily intended it to be at the first we figured we want to get
    8:06
    the people from Germany from Spain from England from um you know France Switzerland all of all of
    8:14
    those countries we want to get them here so they understand that they’re not alone we are already
    8:19
    a group and um yeah that was the whole intent to uh to have that event for that particular goal uh
    8:27
    and with that also grow the communities in the in the in the the the various countries that of
    8:34
    people came from and if I’m proud of one thing is to say that that actually happened because
    8:41
    that happened and spiraled in many many different directions and that’s exactly what we intended

    1. Aditya Avatar

      I really like WordCamp Europe, while I have never had the chance to attend one, I like how communities in Europe got a boost from WCEU in 2013 and I might have shared that view for India too in 2013.

      But India is not EU and we are also in a post pandemic world dealing with post pandemic realities around the community building. I have seen organiser burnout a lot more even as they get involved in local events let alone big events.

  3. yoga1103 Avatar

    Aditya’s thoughts on what a possible WordCamp India would and should look like display not only his experience with the WordPress community, but also a remarkably nuanced reading of the said community.

    To start I will quote some Eastern wisdom/idiom out of context and upside down here: ’50 is not a few, and 20 is not a lot.’

    Back in 2017 India had 10 WordCamps: Mumbai, Pune, Nashik, Nagpur, Ahmedabad, Udaipur, Vadodara, Kochi, Bhopal, Kanpur.In the beginning of 2017, there were 14 WordPress Meetup groups in India.

    Now we have 44 WordPress Meetup groups in India, Mumbai being the oldest and Fatehpur (I’m guessing) the latest. Out of the 44, 20 groups have conducted at least one event in 2024, 13 more had events till last year.

    India has about 45 cities with a 10 lakh (million)+ population, about 400 cities/towns with more than one lakh (100,000) residents. In short, we have 400+ possible WordPress meetup centers.

    In that sense 50 is not a small number really, we are looking at 1 out of 8 urban centers to host a regular WordPress Meetup. In other words ‘50 is not a few.’

    The interesting thing about WordCamps (or any WordPress events) is that everyone who attends them likes the experience. It is an experience that attendees seek again and again, and many of them travel around to attend many WordCamps in a year. Once the attendees understand what it takes to organize a WordCamp/WP Event, they want to replicate it in their own city. Remember 2017 started with 14 meetups and ended with 10 WordCamps.

    Here I make an argument for smaller, easier, and more economical WP events, for example what WordCamp Pune did in 2024: small event, different format, a ton of fun, and a lot of opportunities to learn. Kolhapur attendees saw how easy it was to organize that and now they want to replicate it in their own city. I think not all cities will have a traditional WordCamp, there might be a Kolkata style CareerCamp, a Kerala style WP Photo Festival, a YouthCamp, a KidsCamp, or some other innovative WordPress event.

    If 50 cities/towns have active WP Meetup groups, eventually all of them would want to host some WP event in their own city.

    Active meetups and WordCamps promote the local WordPress ecosystem and people start earning from WordPress, which attracts more talent to WordPress and eventually to the events.

    Once the number of annual events goes higher than 12, we will have more than one event a month and then it will be difficult for attendees to choose which one they want to attend. The variety of WordPress events will enrich the whole ecosystem and hopefully we’ll see more contributors rising from among them.

    In other words ‘20 is a lot.’

    The gauntlet is now thrown, may some capable hands come forward with conviction and clear vision to pick it up. Personally I think this project 50:20 is much more fun and has more value than just a mega-event called WCIndia.

    1. Aditya Avatar

      I want to do things that bring new people into WordPress in a distributed and sustainable manner rather than a concentrated, high-maintenance way.

      I sincerely hope we can do that!

  4. IdeaSmith Avatar

    This feels like a poignant, heartfelt wishlist from someone who has invested a lot of themselves in this community. Whether that will happen or not is anyone’s guess.

    The issue as I see it is, we live in a world that prioritises ‘what do I get out of it’ over any kind of experiential evolution. It’s about transaction rather than evolution. And maybe most people can’t break out of that. The average person that could be part of the WordPress India community has a lot of responsibilities and finds themselves having to ask what they’ll get out of it if they ‘give’ something in return. This isn’t helped by the fact that the media (including social media) cycle has turned attention into currency and weaponised common-interest groups into toxic fandoms.

    So all that remains is either people who will engage ‘out of the goodness of their heart’ and eventually burn out from the exploitation, with resentment. Or those who transact down to the second/byte/rupee and hoard whatever semblance of power that brings.

    Power and transaction are anathema to community.

    Some of the things you’ve been doing in your personal capacity to encourage genuine collaboration are inspiring. But I don’t know if they are sustainable or can be scaled up to the the level of WordCamp India Inc.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from aditya's blog

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading